A brown and white dog beside a white bowl of dry food.

Ollie Review (2026): Is It Worth It?

Ollie scores 9.1 and is our pick for picky eaters thanks to five fresh proteins and a baked food you can mix in, held back by thin public nutrition data.

Good Dog List Editors

Ollie

Bowl Score: 9.1

Best for picky eaters

Rank: 3

Ollie at a glance

Ollie sells gently cooked fresh dog food on a subscription, plus a baked dry food you can feed alone or mix with the fresh. It earns a Bowl Score of 9.1 out of 10, third of the six brands we review in full. Its mix of five fresh recipes and a crunchy baked option makes it the brand we'd try first for a picky eater.

Ollie

Details (as of November 2026)

Bowl Score

9.1 / 10 (ranked 3 of the 6 brands we review in full)

Our label

Best for picky eaters

Best for

Fussy dogs, and owners who want to combine fresh food with a baked food on one plan

Not ideal for

Owners who want full nutrition data on the brand's own site,

Formats

Fresh (gently cooked, frozen or chilled packs), Gently Baked (shelf-stable), treats, and supplements

Storage

Fresh: freezer up to 6 months, 4 days in the fridge once thawed. Baked: pantry, no refrigeration

Subscription

Full Fresh, Half Fresh, or mixed fresh and baked plans; pause or cancel anytime. Also sold at Petco

Our verdict on Ollie

Ollie is a well-made fresh food, and it's the only brand here with a baked food on a standard mixed plan. For a dog that turns its nose up at one texture, having both in the bowl often solves the problem, and the Half Fresh plan lets you use Ollie as a topper over food your dog already eats.

Its recipes are good; it lands third on transparency. Ollie's nutrient numbers are hard to find on its own site (we relied partly on retail labels), and its food is made by third-party manufacturers.

Who Ollie is for, and who should skip it

A good fit if

  • Your dog is picky and you want to try several proteins: Ollie makes fresh beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, and pork recipes.

  • You want to mix fresh food with a crunchy baked food, or feed fresh as a topper on the Half Fresh plan.

  • You'd like the option to buy in a store. Ollie fresh food is sold at Petco.

  • You have a puppy. The fresh recipe statements we read cover all life stages, and the chicken statement adds growth of large-size dogs.

Skip it if

  • You want to read the full guaranteed analysis and calorie content on the brand's site before you buy.

  • Your freezer is small and you want an all-fresh plan. The fresh packs need freezing on arrival.

Ollie plans and delivery (as of November 2026)

Ollie builds each plan from its quiz, and pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. You can choose Full Fresh, Half Fresh (a topper over your dog's current food), or a mix of fresh and baked food. Ollie says it fully refunds the starter box if your dog doesn't like it.

Shipping is free on subscriptions, and you can change delivery timing, swap recipes, pause, or cancel. Ollie's terms say to cancel at least six days before your next delivery to avoid a charge.

Ollie recipes and ingredients

Recipe

Line

First five ingredients

Chicken Dish with Carrots

Fresh

Chicken, rice, carrots, chicken livers, peas

Beef Dish with Sweet Potatoes

Fresh

Beef, carrots, beef kidneys, potatoes, peas

Turkey Dish with Blueberries

Fresh

Turkey, butternut squash, turkey livers, oats, lentils

Lamb Dish with Cranberries

Fresh

Lamb, butternut squash, lamb liver, chickpeas, kale

Pork with Apples

Fresh

Pork, pork livers, butternut squash, rice, sweet potatoes

Gently Baked Chicken with Carrots

Baked

Chicken first (full list on the bag)

Gently Baked Beef with Sweet Potatoes

Baked

Not published

Fresh ingredient lists come from Ollie's retail packaging as reproduced by a stockist. Every fresh recipe leads with a named meat, and all five include organ meat in the top five. Ollie says it uses USDA-certified, human-grade ingredients, and its blog says the food is cooked in U.S. kitchens run by third-party manufacturers (its nutrition page says North American facilities), which Dog Food Advisor describes as SQF-certified facilities. Ollie also sells treats and three daily supplements (a probiotic, a calming formula, and a hip and joint chew).

Ollie nutrition analysis

Ollie says its recipes are formulated by veterinary nutritionists, and in September 2026 it described its team as two board-certified veterinary nutritionists on consultation plus two in-house veterinarians. Recipes are built in a nutrient database and then checked by chemical analysis against the full AAFCO profile. Ollie doesn't mention a feeding trial. The fresh recipe statements we read say each is formulated to meet AAFCO's nutrient profiles for all life stages.

We compare foods on a dry-matter basis so that water doesn't distort the numbers:

  • Dry matter (%) = 100 minus moisture %

  • Nutrient, dry-matter basis (%) = label % divided by dry matter %, times 100

Example: Turkey Dish with Blueberries lists 10% protein and 72% moisture, so dry matter is 28% and protein is 10 / 28 x 100, or about 35.7%.

Recipe

Label: protein / fat / fiber / moisture

Dry-matter protein

Dry-matter fat

Dry-matter fiber (max)

kcal/kg

Fresh Chicken

8% / 3% / 2% / 74%

30.8%

11.5%

7.7%

1,298

Fresh Beef

9% / 7% / 2% / 72%

32.1%

25.0%

7.1%

1,540

Fresh Turkey

10% / 7% / 2% / 72%

35.7%

25.0%

7.1%

1,540

Fresh Lamb

9% / 7% / 2% / 72%

32.1%

25.0%

7.1%

1,540

Fresh Pork

9% / 7% / 2% / 72%

32.1%

25.0%

7.1%

1,540

Baked Beef

23% / 13% / 4% / 10%

25.6%

14.4%

4.4%

Not published

Label figures are minimums for protein and fat and maximums for fiber and moisture, so these are estimates. The chicken recipe is the lean one, at about 11.5% dry-matter fat, which makes it worth asking your vet about for a dog that needs a lower-fat diet. The other four fresh recipes sit around 25% fat on a dry-matter basis. The baked beef recipe is lower in protein than the fresh food once water is removed, so a plan that leans heavily on baked food will deliver less protein per bowl. Baked Beef figures come from a third-party review site, and Ollie doesn't publish calories for its baked recipes.

Ollie quality and testing

Formulation. Ollie says veterinary nutritionists formulate its recipes, which are built in a nutrient database and checked by chemical analysis against the full AAFCO profile. Ollie says it uses USDA-certified, human-grade ingredients, and Dog Food Advisor reports the food is made in SQF-certified facilities.

Transparency. Ollie answers several of the WSAVA's suggested questions on its blog, including who formulates its food and how recipes are checked. It's weaker on public data: its nutrition pages were hard to access when we checked, and it doesn't run its own kitchens.

Handling. Thaw fresh packs in the fridge for about 24 hours, use them within four days, and don't refreeze thawed food. If your dog has vomiting or diarrhea that lasts more than a day or two after switching, stop the new food and call your vet.

What Ollie owners say

On Trustpilot, Ollie had a TrustScore of 4.7 out of 5 from 11,347 reviews when we checked on November 18, 2026, with 84% of reviews at five stars and 4% at one star. That's the largest Trustpilot review count of the six brands we review in full. Dog Food Advisor gives all five fresh recipes its top rating.

Ollie vs Spot & Tango and The Farmer's Dog


Ollie

Spot & Tango

The Farmer's Dog

Bowl Score

9.1

9.4

9.5

Formats

Fresh (frozen) + baked

Fresh (frozen) + UnKibble (shelf-stable)

Fresh (frozen) + Instant Fresh (shelf-stable, adult only)

Fresh recipes

5 (beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, pork)

3 Fresh + 3 UnKibble

Beef, chicken, turkey, pork

Who formulates

Board-certified veterinary nutritionists on consultation

Vet nutritionists, per the brand

Named on-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists

Compare

-

Ollie vs Spot & Tango

The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie

Spot & Tango is the closest alternative for an owner who wants both a fresh food and a shelf-stable one from the same brand, and customer support can set up a plan that mixes the two lines. Its UnKibble, which the brand says is gently cooked and dried at low temperatures, lives in the pantry, and the brand publishes calories and guaranteed analysis on every recipe page. Read our Spot & Tango review for the full picture. The Farmer's Dog suits owners who want an all-fresh plan and a named nutrition team; see our Farmer's Dog review.

How we scored Ollie

We score every brand on the same six weighted criteria: Nutrition & formulation 30%, Value 20%, Ingredient quality & sourcing 15%, Safety & transparency 15%, Convenience & storage 10%, and Plan flexibility 10%. Ollie scored well on ingredients, with named meats and organ meats high on every fresh label, and on flexibility, thanks to its Half Fresh and mixed plans and Petco availability. It lost points on safety and transparency for third-party manufacturing and nutrition data that's hard to find on its own site. The full method is on our how we rank page.

FAQs

Is Ollie good for picky eaters?

It's our pick for them. Ollie offers five fresh proteins and a baked food you can mix in, so you can change both flavor and texture without changing brands. Introduce any new food over about a week, and talk to your vet if your dog suddenly stops eating, since that can signal a health problem.

How much does Ollie cost?

Pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. Ollie quotes it after a short quiz about your dog, and a Half Fresh plan, which tops your dog's current food, uses less fresh food than Full Fresh.

Can you buy Ollie without a subscription?

Ollie's site sells by subscription; Petco sells baked bags without one, and Ollie's blog says its fresh food is sold at Petco too. Subscriptions can be paused or canceled at any time.

Who makes Ollie dog food?

Ollie formulates its recipes with veterinary nutritionists and uses third-party manufacturers to cook them in U.S. kitchens, per Ollie's blog (its nutrition page says North American facilities). Dog Food Advisor reports those kitchens are SQF-certified food safety facilities.