A small black, white and tan dog against a warm pink background.

About Good Dog List

Who writes Good Dog List

Good Dog List is written and maintained by Good Dog List Editors, a small team that compares dog food brands: fresh, gently cooked, air-dried, and dehydrated delivery services, plus the kibble brands on our main ranking. We cover the questions people ask before they subscribe: what's actually in the bowl, how it ships and stores, and how easy it is to pause or cancel.

Good Dog List is operated in partnership with Spot & Tango, one of the brands we rank.

How we put a review together

Every review starts from primary sources. We read each brand's recipe pages, guaranteed analysis, calorie content, AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement, and subscription terms. Then we convert the numbers so foods with very different moisture levels can be compared fairly, with protein on a dry-matter basis.

Each brand gets a Bowl Score out of 10 from the same six weighted criteria. The full rubric and the formulas are on the how we rank page.

What we don't do

  • We don't give individual veterinary advice. If your dog has a health condition, your vet should guide the choice of food.

  • We don't print a spec we can't trace to a source. When a brand doesn't publish a number, our tables say "Not published."

  • We don't score outside our rubric. Scores follow our published criteria, and our advertising disclosure explains how the site earns money.

Keeping pages current

Fresh dog food brands change recipes and plan terms often. Each page shows the date its facts were last checked.

FAQs

Are Good Dog List's reviews written by veterinarians?

No. Good Dog List Editors are dog food researchers, not veterinarians, and we don't present our reviews as veterinary advice. We work from brand labels and published nutrition data, and we point readers to their own vet for medical questions.

Do you test the food yourselves?

Our scores come from published data: labels, calorie content, AAFCO statements, and plan terms. We don't run lab tests, so every number on the site traces back to a published source.