Two happy dogs sitting together on green grass.

The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie (2026): The Farmer's Dog for fully fresh, Ollie for picky eaters

The Farmer's Dog edges Ollie 9.5 to 9.1 as our best overall fresh plan, while Ollie suits picky eaters with five proteins and mixed fresh-and-baked boxes.

Good Dog List Editors

Key takeaways

  • The Farmer's Dog (9.5) is our best overall fresh plan; Ollie (9.1) suits picky eaters and owners who want to mix formats.

  • Ollie has five fresh proteins (beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, pork) and two baked recipes. The Farmer's Dog has four fresh proteins and two Instant Fresh recipes.

  • The Farmer's Dog's vet portal says its recipes are backed by an AAFCO feeding trial. Ollie formulates to AAFCO nutrient profiles and doesn't mention feeding trials.

  • Both now sell a shelf-stable line. Ollie's baked food can share a box with fresh packs; The Farmer's Dog Instant Fresh is sold one-time or on a plan.

Which is better, The Farmer's Dog or Ollie?

If you have freezer room and want a fully fresh diet, The Farmer's Dog is the one to pick. Its recipes are formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists on staff, and its vet portal cites an AAFCO feeding trial.

Ollie wins for dogs that get bored or fussy. Five fresh proteins give you more to rotate, and Ollie's plans can mix fresh and baked food or serve fresh as a half portion on top of what your dog already eats. It's also on Petco shelves, which helps if you run out between deliveries.

The short version, question by question

If you're asking...

Our pick

Why

Which is better overall?

The Farmer's Dog (9.5)

Feeding-trial backing and named board-certified nutritionists

Which is better for a picky eater?

Ollie (9.1)

Five fresh proteins and mixed fresh-and-baked plans

Which works as a topper?

Ollie

Its half-fresh plan is built for topping

Which has more protein?

The Farmer's Dog

Its fresh beef shows 39.3% protein on a dry-matter basis on third-party label data vs 32.1% for Ollie's fresh beef

Which is easier to find in a store?

Ollie

Sold at Petco; The Farmer's Dog sells fresh food on Walmart.com

Which is better without freezer space?

Neither, fully

Both shelf-stable lines are limited to two recipes; see our no-freezer ranking

How The Farmer's Dog and Ollie compare

Recipes and variety

Ollie's fresh line covers beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, and pork. The Farmer's Dog covers beef, chicken, turkey, and pork, with grain-free and grain-inclusive versions (the grain is oats). For shelf-stable food, Ollie bakes beef and chicken recipes, and The Farmer's Dog sells Instant Fresh in beef and chicken.

Nutrition and formulation

Both brands say their recipes are formulated by veterinary nutritionists. The Farmer's Dog names its board-certified nutritionists on its vet portal and says its recipes are backed by an AAFCO feeding trial. Ollie formulates to AAFCO nutrient profiles for all life stages, checks each recipe by lab analysis, and doesn't mention feeding trials. The Farmer's Dog's fresh recipes suit puppies, adults, and seniors, but its Instant Fresh is labeled for adult maintenance only. Edge: The Farmer's Dog.

Storage

Fresh packs from both arrive frozen or very cold, keep up to six months in the freezer, and last up to four days in the fridge once thawed. Ollie's baked food is reported to last six weeks after opening. The Farmer's Dog Instant Fresh should be used within three months of opening and kept no more than two days in the fridge once water is added. Storage is a wash for fresh food; the shelf-stable lines differ more in prep than in shelf life.

Plans and trial

Both brands build a plan from a short quiz about your dog, and both ship free. Ollie says it fully refunds the starter box if your dog doesn't like it, and its Half Fresh plan uses less fresh food by topping what your dog already eats.

Quality and testing

The Farmer's Dog's vet site says its food is made and tested in FDA-registered facilities. Ollie uses third-party manufacturers, which Dog Food Advisor reports are SQF-certified facilities. Neither brand publishes full fresh-recipe labels openly: The Farmer's Dog keeps its Fresh-line labels behind signup (its Instant Fresh pages publish guaranteed analysis and calories), and Ollie's numbers are spread across sample and nutrition-facts pages. The Farmer's Dog also faces a pending class action, filed in April 2026, over the fat content of its food; the company calls it baseless. Edge: The Farmer's Dog, for its named nutrition team and stated feeding trial.

Plan flexibility

Both let you pause, cancel, and reschedule. Ollie's mixed and half-fresh plans give you more ways to set up a box. Edge: Ollie.

Specs side by side

Feature

The Farmer's Dog

Ollie

Bowl Score

9.5

9.1

Our label

Best overall fresh plan

Best for picky eaters

Formats

Fresh (frozen); Instant Fresh (shelf-stable, add water)

Fresh (frozen); Baked (shelf-stable)

Fresh proteins

Beef, chicken, turkey, pork

Beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, pork

Plan types

Fresh plan; Instant Fresh one-time or on a plan

Full fresh, half fresh, mixed fresh and baked

AAFCO

Complete and balanced; vet portal cites a feeding trial

All life stages (formulation)

Who formulates

On-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists

Veterinary nutritionists (consulting) and in-house vets

Fridge life once thawed

Up to four days

Up to four days

Retail

Walmart.com

Petco

Delivery

About one week to two months of food per box; free shipping

Flexible schedule you can change; free shipping

Nutrition on a dry-matter basis

Metric

TFD Fresh Beef*

TFD Instant Fresh Chicken

Ollie Fresh Beef

Ollie Fresh Turkey

Protein (as fed)

11%

37%

9%

10%

Moisture (max)

72%

7.5%

72%

72%

Protein, dry matter

39.3%

40.0%

32.1%

35.7%

Calories

Not published

3,525 kcal/kg

1,540 kcal/kg

1,540 kcal/kg

Protein, grams per 1,000 kcal

Not calculable

105.0 g

58.4 g

64.9 g

*The Farmer's Dog shows full fresh nutrition only after its signup quiz; these come from a third-party label review, and we couldn't confirm a calorie figure. Instant Fresh figures are from the brand's product page. Ollie's come from its sample and nutrition-facts pages.

On these numbers, The Farmer's Dog's fresh beef carries more protein on a dry-matter basis, and its Instant Fresh Chicken is unusually protein-dense at 105 g per 1,000 kcal.

Picking between them

Go with The Farmer's Dog if

  • You want a fully fresh diet with feeding-trial backing

  • Your dog does well on chicken, pork, or a grain-free recipe

  • You want named board-certified veterinary nutritionists behind the recipes

Go with Ollie if

  • Your dog is picky and needs rotation, including lamb

  • You want fresh and baked food in one box, or a half-fresh topper plan

  • You'd like to buy at Petco

If freezer space is the sticking point, our The Farmer's Dog vs Spot & Tango comparison covers a shelf-stable alternative. Full scoring is in our The Farmer's Dog review and Ollie review.

FAQs

Is The Farmer's Dog better than Ollie?

For a fully fresh plan, yes: The Farmer's Dog scores 9.5 to Ollie's 9.1, helped by its feeding-trial backing and named board-certified nutritionists. Ollie is the better pick for picky eaters and mixed fresh-and-baked plans.

How much do The Farmer's Dog and Ollie cost?

Pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. Both brands quote after a short quiz, so get a quote from each.

Does The Farmer's Dog have a shelf-stable option like Ollie's baked food?

Yes. The Farmer's Dog launched Instant Fresh in 2026, a shelf-stable food in beef and chicken that you mix with water. It's labeled for adult maintenance, so it isn't meant for puppies.

Which has more recipes?

Ollie, with five fresh proteins (including lamb) plus two baked recipes. The Farmer's Dog has four fresh proteins and two Instant Fresh recipes.